Beethoven's 10th Symphony - yes, 10th!
How many here have heard Beethoven's 10th Symphony? (c'mon Bernard - fess up
)
I picked this CD up a few months ago and am just now rediscovering it's charms. Of course most of us know that Beethoven never published a 10th Symphony, but he did draw up an initial frame-work and apparently even wrote a fair amount for at least one instrument. Fast Forward to modern day, a noted Beethoven scholar and accomplished composer Prof. Barry Cooper has taken up the task of completing Beethoven's work. While surely quite different from whatever Beethoven would have eventually realized, IMO, Cooper's realization is far from unpleasant.
You can play a sample here:
http://www.jpc.de/jpcng/classic/det...en-1770-1827-Tripelkonzert-op-56/hnum/6024783
For anyone interested, I borrowed the following from a recent BBC posting:
Beethoven wrote the slow movement for his string quartet Opus 18 Number Two in 1799 before discarding it and composing another version a year later.
The original has not survived, but has now been reconstructed by Prof Barry Cooper of Manchester University.
He has reassembled the surviving sketches, filling in any gaps himself.
Prof Cooper, one of the world's leading experts on the composer, said preliminary sketches from Beethoven's notebooks had survived for all 74 bars of the movement.
But half of the bars were written for just one instrument, meaning Prof Cooper has completed the missing instrument parts himself.
"You've got a pretty good idea of what the music is like," he told BBC News.
"The movement will certainly be strikingly similar to what Beethoven wrote. Obviously it can't possibly be exactly the same."
The original movement was delivered to Beethoven's patron Prince Franz Joseph Maximilian von Lobkowitz in 1799 before being replaced with a revised version.
'A perfectionist'
The full manuscript of the original composition has not been seen since. But Beethoven wrote to a friend in 1801, telling him that he had not mastered the composition of quartets at the time that he wrote the original.
"He was a perfectionist," Prof Cooper said. "He felt that when he wrote this early movement, he didn't actually know how to write quartets. Any other composer would have been delighted to have written this lovely movement."
The completed movement will be performed by the university's resident string quartet Quatuor Danel at the Martin Harris Centre in Manchester on Thursday.
The performance comes 13 years after Prof Cooper stirred controversy in the classical music world by creating a 10th Symphony based on unfinished Beethoven sketches.
He said there was "far more" evidence for the contents of the string quartet than for the symphony, meaning it was "much easier to piece together".