I think Jeff's assesment is essentially correct. The giant killer tag comes from the fact that there is only one other 'Swiss Army Knife" player out there to date and that is the Denon A1UDCI which retails for about $4000.00. The debate rages as to whether the Denon is 8 times better than the OPPO BDP-83.
And if you want a Bluray only player then you certainly can get one for less than 500 bucks. Heck I will sell you a perfectly good Sony BDP-S1 for 50 bucks, if all you want is Bluray......just PM me on the BDP-S1.
So far my BDP-S1 has played every Bluray that I have put in it and I have over 100 Blurays collected so far, yeah I know that's dumb but at the moment Bluray is just the latest in a long line of dead formats.
But if you happen to have a multi-channel HT system with a single HDMI connection that is no muss and no fuss or you want an analogue connection between your UDP and your older HT processor.
And you happen to own some dead or dying audio formats and some dead or dying dvd formats and some dead or dying digital music formats and some dead or dying Bluray formats, well then...........I believe the argument can be made that all formats are dying, in fact that argument has been made many times.....even our own Bernard has said that all great men are dead and even he feels sick.....but I digress.
Anyway, I think the main point about the Oppo is good luck trying to beat the Oppo BDP-83 in value and technical ability. It does more things well or better than any other player out there, more being the operative word. I guess it is just refreshing to see a product come along that does so many things well and at such an affordable price point.
I have beta tested many products but I have never beta tested a product that was as mature and well developed as the Oppo BDP-83 and the way they marketed the BDP-83 was unique, you gotta give Oppo a little credit for selling the BDP-83 via a lottery.
Again, I think that is why the BDP-83 is getting praise and it is real users that are praising it not just reviewers, until Jeff that is
And just one last thing and it is not trivial. Read the AVS forum threads about Oppo and see if you can find another Bluray manufacturer that gets as high a praise for customer service as Oppo does.
Okay, Jim Power at ML doesn't count, although I heard that ML is coming out with a line of Amps and components tuned to Electrostats and that a Universal Player including Bluray was in the works.....................Okay I made that last part up....Except about Jim Power and how good ML customer service is.