I have around 500 LPs, a Michell Gyrodec that is around 17-18 years old, a Moerch DP6 (replaced a Rega RB300 - major upgrade sonically) that's around 10 years old, a Trichord Delphini phono stage (3-4 years old) and a Transfiguration Orpheus, recently acquired. I bought the Gyrodec new after getting hold of some Wimbledon Men's final tickets, and flogging them for a lot more than face value.
With my MF TriVista out of action, I'm using a £200 Teac CD player as a backup - believe me - it ISN'T good!
So this past week I have been spinning a lot of vinyl. The Orpheus must be getting close to what can be retrieved off a disc. I am pretty staggered by it, to be honest. It definately produces a sound that is more highly resolved that digital - there's a wealth more detail in the playback of well produced discs. Even "Never Mind The Bollocks - Here's The Sex Pistols" had my tongue dropping out last night - I have never heard it sound so good. Bought around the time of it's release, it has been played many, many times over the years. After a few beers, admitedly, but it just blew me away! The original pressing, at least, was a very, very well produced disc.
Hell, with discs produced from digital sources, it even naturally oversamples to "continuous" resolution - beat that, CD player!
But it comes at a price of noise, clicks, pops etc - all the usual vinyl moans and groans...
There's life in the old girl yet... but you have to source a good deck etc. It needn't cost a lot if you go for some old classic components on the 2nd hand market.
And let's face it - if you have the $$$, a top end Clearaudio or Transrotor TT are just amazing machines to behold. Again, beat that, CD player - though there are some wacky designs, mostly emulating TTs...